För att använda dessa tillägg måste du ladda ner Firefox.

Logga in
Ikon för tillägg

Recensioner för Bookmarks Organizer

Bookmarks Organizer av Sören Hentzschel

3,7 stjärnor av 5
5
182
4
65
3
31
2
29
1
75
Recension av MediaPuck
av MediaPuck, för 6 år sedan
Hi, am perfectly willing to change my rating - but as of right now = I get zero results. I had it run one week ago for a full day. It simply showed "0" on everything.
I have 124792 bookmarks [well, am online since 1993 :)]
So, it is virtually impossible that there is none broken, or double etc. I know for a fact that I have at least over 20 thousand doubles, because of a inadvertent new import after Xmars closed.
That was my reason for installing your extension, hoping to clean first before I use bookmarks also with my FVD account I have for speed dials.

Yes, of course I can do a manual check and clean with the library, but this would be silly if a extension like yours exist.
I have:
Firefox quantum 60.0.2
Your extension version: 2.0.1
I read over every comment here without being able to determine anything to solve my problem.
Hoping you will respond to the low star mark - and maybe there is an explanation for zero results.

I also tried it on my laptop, that is not synced to anything. The only identical setup is the old Xmarks bookmark folder structure.
I always kept the Xmarks clean on all my cpu's [had used them from their initiation date].
I should be able to get at least some number of duplicates from your extension.
Tests I did following last weeks zero result after an entire day run: Tried also with a new mozilla profile,
but still get no results.
I see that others here have no problem, so I need to find out what and why I get no results.
Kind regards,
Michele
Ps: ich spreche auch Deutsch, sollte das fuer sie einfacher sein.

Utvecklarens svar

postad för 10 månader sedan
Can you please test again with a current version and re-review? Thanks!
382 recensioner
  • av Firefox-användare 18438269, för 4 dagar sedan
  • av Firefox-användare 18358696, för 25 dagar sedan
    Excellent. Sorted out >2000 bookmarks agregated over the past 25 years.
  • av Tom, för en månad sedan
    4 mal probiert. Entweder passiert garnix oder FF stürzt ab. Schade

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för en månad sedan
    Dir müsste selbst klar sein, dass das nicht normal sein kann. Wieso man dann das Bewertungssystem missbraucht statt einen Fehler beim Entwickler zu melden, erschließt sich mir nicht. Folgendes sind Tatsachen:

    - Es ist bei mir nicht eine einzige Fehlermeldung eingegangen, was das MINDESTE sein sollte, bevor man jemanden schlecht bewertet.
    - Es passiert nichts und Firefox stürzt ab sind zwei komplett unterschiedliche Symptome. Und von beidem höre ich nach so vielen Jahren an dieser Stelle zum allerersten Mal überhaupt.
    - Wenn Firefox abstürzt, ist das ein Problem von Firefox, nicht der Erweiterung. Die Erweiterung kann nicht für die Stabilität des Browsers verantwortlich gemacht werden.

    In einer Sache gebe ich dir recht: Schade. So eine Vorgehensweise finde ich wirklich sehr schade. Da opfert man seine Freizeit, um anderen Nutzern kostenlos etwas zur Verfügung zu stellen, und wenn etwas nicht wie gewünscht klappt, wird erst einmal schlecht bewertet statt konstruktives Feedback an den Entwickler zu geben. Das motiviert nicht gerade, weiterhin kostenlos Dinge zur Verfügung zu stellen.
  • av Firefox-användare 17862970, för 3 månader sedan
  • av Firefox-användare 14366081, för 4 månader sedan
    Review-Update: Einige Bookmarks werden kommentarlos als fehlerhaft angezeigt, obwohl sie sich ganz normal öffnen lassen. Es sollte der Grund angezeigt werden, warum es einen Fehler gibt. Im Ergebnis werden bei mir 12/437 Lesezeichen als false positives angezeigt. Insbesondere mit Google-Seiten scheint die Erweiterung Probleme zu haben.
    Im Vergleich dazu zeigt die Erweiterung "Bookmarks clean up" immer einen Grund an. Hier gab es aber nur ein false positive wegen eines Timeout, der nach erneutem Test auch nur temporär war, sprich keine systematische Anzeige von Lesezeichen als fehlerhaft.

    Einträge ohne Namen werden aufgrund des fehlenden Grundes genauso angezeigt wie in der Suche nach leeren Namen. Daher entsteht der Eindruck, der Grund sei der fehlende Name. Das ist ein Problem des Interfaces.

    Der einzige Vorteil dieser Extension ist, dass man Weiterleitungen auf einen Klick übernehmen kann.
  • av MKL.MH, för 5 månader sedan
    Super facile à utiliser, merci
  • av Teagan, för 5 månader sedan
    This Add-On Might Work, BUT . . .

    So, first I encourage everyone to read the "About this extension" section before using the extension to familiarize yourself with a few things like it's Features, Shortcuts and Planned features. Now, the 'Bookmarks Organizer' does what it claims. However, there are some things that the developer didn't think of. One of them and maybe the most important, is a Pause and/or Stop button. Having a Pause and/or Stop Button would be helpful for anyone that has 5000 - 10000+ bookmarks, for the following reasons; It would allow anyone using this extension to pause it and/or stop it, so they could go through the bookmarks that have already been scanned. The other reason is that, if you expect this scan to only take 10 to 25 minutes, think again, especially if your a bookmark addict and you have 5000 - 10000+ bookmarks saved. Because with that many bookmarks saved it's going to take a ... a few hours if not more.
    The only other thing I can think of is something that apparently will be added to an up and coming version of the extension. That the ability or the option to 'select multiple bookmarks at once rather than only being able to delete them one by one'. Other than that, give this extension a try, it does work. It's a little slow, but it works. I gave it 3 Stars, but I would have given it 5 stars if it wasn't so slow.
  • av Firefox-användare 15329826, för 6 månader sedan
    Don't mind the negative reviews - they are haters who ruin their time...
    This plug-in is fantastic, simple to use and very efficient to clean up the bookmarks.
    It does what it's intended to and in a very clear way.
    Thanks to Sören for this well craft piece of software !

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 6 månader sedan
    Thank you very much! :)
  • av IT retired, för 6 månader sedan
    5+ stars. What a great piece of software. It is very handy, works like a charm and saves a shi* load of manual work. Please don't get demotivated by all the nincompoops that rate you 1 star. Good stuff!

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 6 månader sedan
    Thank you very much! :)
  • av Francesco, för 7 månader sedan
    good , but many websites change address and website topic. U should add the new website title if different to old one, so we can change both at same time otherwise we must add new website and delete old on

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 7 månader sedan
    Thanks for the review.

    Most websites will add redirects if the address changes. And Bookmarks Organizer already detects redirects so that you can change your bookmarks. So that part is already implemented.

    For the name of the bookmark it's not possible to know if the name was set by the user or not. Many people don't use the website's title as the bookmark's name. I don't understand the "otherwise we must add new website and delete old on" part.
  • av spintike, för 7 månader sedan
    Mein Dank gilt dem Entwickler der Erweiterung! Die Funktionen sind so wie beschrieben & genau, was ich gesucht habe.
  • av Firefox-användare 13571539, för 8 månader sedan
    Gruß Gott! :)

    Honestly, there's not much I can write about yet, as I've only just installed and started the thing running for the first time.

    Mainly I posted a review to chime in with others I've seen here, that being able to check specific folders would be a good feature to have.

    Actually, that was the feature I was specifically looking for. I wasn't all that keen on the last extension I used for bookmark checking, and was hoping to find something that could do more targeted checking. (At almost 3k bookmarks, I suspect even the best programs would plod getting through that many...)

    This one seemed to come more highly recommended, though, so I decided to give it a try anyway. So far so good. I only just installed and launched a few minutes ago and it's already halfway-through....
  • av Usuário FF 17151627, för 8 månader sedan
  • av Alam, för 9 månader sedan
  • av Joseph, för 9 månader sedan
    would be good if can select mutiple selections at once rather than deleting one by one

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 9 månader sedan
    It's on the roadmap for a future update.
  • av Firefox-användare 14644415, för 9 månader sedan
    suite a mes déboire avec un profil abimé et l'extension bugué (ver:4.1.0), la version 4.1.1 me fait remettre 5 étoiles pour cette formidable extension et surtout merci a sont concepteur pour avoir répondu a mon e-mail. ;)

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 9 månader sedan
    This is not true at all. The Bookmarks Organizer works with Firefox ESR 102. You can't use the latest version but you don't need the latest version. There were no new features at all. Firefox ESR 102 is EOL so there is no point in supporting it with newer versions of the add-on.
  • av Giorgos, för 9 månader sedan
    Very useful add-on for bookmark cleaning.

    Suggestions for the next version:

    1. Ability to run on specific Bookmark folders only

    2. Ability to filter (as well as apply cleaning) specific Bookmarks or Bookmark folders in results

    3. Ability to save backups for bad bookmarks before deletion/correction

    Using checkboxes in tree view for 1 and 2 would be great

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 9 månader sedan
    Thank you for your review and feedback!

    You can already do backups with the tools Firefox provide. It's nothing a WebExtension can provide. 1 and 2 are good ideas.
  • av Panos K., för 10 månader sedan
    Excellent addon. Lately seems to have a bug that causes the addon to not finish checking. I submitted an issue on Github.

    Addon v4.1 seems to be OK. No more neverending loop. Checking 277 bookmarks completed as expected.

    Firefox Nightly 118.0a1 (2023-08-16) (64-bit)

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Hello,

    can you please test again with Bookmarks Organizer 4.1? Thank you!
  • av Thomas, för 10 månader sedan
  • av LAD, för ett år sedan
    Fantastic for cleaning up bookmarks, worked great for finding broken and duplicate links.

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Thank you!
  • av Firefox-användare 13572610, för ett år sedan
  • av matheuslyderis, för ett år sedan
    Awesome Addon!
    Works very nice and easy.
    Congrats to dev(s)

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Thank you!
  • av silvatek, för ett år sedan
    Superb at sorting out the wheat from the chaff, but I need something which will help me organize bookmarks. To be fair, this does what it claims to do, but it's only halfway to what I need.

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Thank you!

    I agree that more features for organizing bookmarks would be nice.
  • av yuleself, för ett år sedan
    很方便的小工具。如果清理书签时，能实时显示结果就更好了。Very handy little tool. It would be even better if the results can be displayed in real time when cleaning bookmarks.

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Thank you!

    That's a nice idea. I am not sure if it's possible with the curent architecture of Bookmarks Organizer. That's something I have to investigate.
  • av MrMorph, för ett år sedan
    Everything worked as advertised for me and saved me a lot of time going through nearly 3000 bookmarks. It scans and finds all the dead ones and problem links like HTTP to HTTPS. It also helped me remove duplicates. Perfect - thanks; I sent the cost of a coffee your way :)

    Utvecklarens svar

    postad för 10 månader sedan
    Thank you very much!